All articles

Generatie Z

Ronald Dekker: ‘Generational thinking is rampant weed’

Generational differences? They sound very appealing, but scientifically they are always shoddy work, Ronald Dekker emphasises. So why do we keep proving so susceptible to them?

Ronald Dekker: ‘Generational thinking is rampant weed’

Generational thinking is the rampant weed of the social sciences. And of labour market research in particular. It spreads like mad through public and political debate, and it is virtually impossible to eradicate root and branch. There, I have said it.

In recent weeks, VVD parliamentary leader Ruben Brekelmans said something in a lecture that really would not do. Namely, that newly qualified young people, when entering the labour market, should work only 4, or even just 3 days. Even when they have absolutely no children to care for, or any other good excuse. So says VVD member Ruben Brekelmans.

Cuckoo clocks

He put it quite precisely, speaking about new entrants and young people in the labour market. But in the discussion that followed, for example on social media, all the generational thinkers popped out of their cuckoo clocks again like little birds.

Cuckoo! Surely we can all see around us that young people today have a very different work ethic from the age cohorts before them? And they use the rampant-weed word ‘generations’ instead of age cohorts. And worse still, they use the now well-established terms that journalists and politicians are so fond of too: Gen Z, Millennials and Boomers.

‘Terms such as Gen Z were invented by shoddy scientists.’

Those terms were invented by shoddy scientists who have tried desperately to find distinguishing group characteristics for age cohorts. And they gave those age cohorts labels. The hypothesis of those scientists is that they can find significant differences between those groups. For example, that Millennials would have different part-time work preferences from Gen Zers.

Giving labels

Now, formulating a hypothesis about differences in group characteristics is of course not a problem. Social scientists do nothing else. They study differences between men and women, young and old people, academically and vocationally educated people, Rotterdam residents and Amsterdam residents, city dwellers and rural residents. And that is fine, because it helps us understand the world and the people around us better.

Formulating hypotheses about differences in group characteristics is not the problem.

But comparing groups of Millennials and Gen Zers as age cohorts (never call them generations!) is scientifically problematic, especially when you are interested in the preferences and behaviour of ‘new entrants to the labour market’. Think about it: here and now, Gen Zers are of course not new entrants. They were 25 to 30 years ago.

Shoddy science

So, if you want to compare the work ethic of Millennials and Gen Zers in a scientifically sound way, you need empirical information from 30 years ago about the behaviour and preferences of Gen Zers. Cuckoo! You usually do not have that information (read: extremely rarely). And so there are shoddy scientists who cling to the generational framework and use information about the preferences and behaviour of Gen Zers here and now to compare it with the preferences and behaviour of Millennials.

Cuckoo! What you are doing then is research into age differences. Or differences in life stage. Yet the results, even in academic journals, are presented as identified ‘generational differences’.

Age, life stage or cohort?

Very occasionally, a researcher does make a serious attempt to find ‘real’ differences between age cohorts. For example, on the basis of long-term (>30 years) research into the preferences and behaviour of people in the labour market. You then have to make assumptions about what differences between people can be attributed to, and make methodological choices based on those assumptions. Are the differences found related to age, life stage or age cohort?

The few effects found are always small.

The ‘econometric’ problem is that the variables age and life stage together are quite good predictors of the variable age cohort. There is a methodological solution to that problem, with which I shall not bore the reader now. That method can isolate (identify) the effect of age cohort as well as possible. The effects found for age cohorts sometimes differ significantly from 0, but usually they do not. The few effects found are therefore always small.

No future!

Cuckoo! You see, generational differences really do exist. Yes, that is true in the sense that you can find significant differences between age cohorts. But those differences can partly be attributed to changed circumstances. For example, it makes quite a difference to new entrants to the labour market what the economy and labour market are like.

People who are the same age as me entered the labour market as young people during the no future! period of the 1980s and displayed different behaviour then from the young people who entered the labour market in the 1990s, when the economy was booming. But that difference is not necessarily a difference in the preferences of a generation, but a difference in external circumstances.

‘Generational differences do not exist! Basket!’

Long story short: for all practical purposes, it is better not to attach too much value to the assumed differences between age cohorts. Or, even shorter: generational differences do not exist! Basket!

About the author

Ronald Dekker is an independent labour economist at RoDeO Labour market intelligence.

Read also

Related posts

All articles
How the practical training room is increasingly becoming the answer to staff shortages

Yesterday, another large practical training workshop opened in Tilburg, where the installers of tomorrow are being trained. Organisations are increasingly turning to their own practical training schools. Will they succeed in addressing the shortages?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
From Gaming to Air Traffic Control: Why the FAA Is Recruiting Gamer

It's not a game. It's a career. Met die boodschap is de Amerikaanse luchtverkeersleiding FAA een nieuwe campagne gestart. Voornaamste doelgroep: videogamers. Uit data bleek namelijk dat 248 (!) van de 250 afgestudeerden dat zijn.

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
Striking: women are least concerned about the impact of AI on the labour market

Dutch women are less concerned about the impact of A.I. on their work than men, recent research shows. This is striking, as women more often work in professions that feel the effects of generative A.I. more strongly. What exactly is going on?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.