All articles

News

The 3 most important fallacies in thinking about labour productivity

The government recently approved the so-called Productivity Agenda. But are they sufficiently aware of the biggest fallacies when it comes to productivity, Ronald Dekker wonders.

The 3 most important fallacies in thinking about labour productivity

Productivity must increase. That is what Draghi and Wennink called for, and it is now also what the Jetten government is calling for. They say this because economists can explain precisely that productivity, and labour productivity in particular, is the main source of prosperity growth. Just consider it: if more people work more hours, value is also created that leads to greater prosperity, but if more value can be created without deploying additional human hours, that is of course better. If only because, for most people, ‘enjoying leisure time’ also represents value.

For most people, ‘enjoying leisure time’ also represents value…

At a time of a structurally tight labour market, it is therefore important to ensure that people create more value per hour worked. This value creation through paid work has long been central to economic policy. And the recent emphasis on labour productivity is no exception. But if you take off your economist’s glasses for a moment, or have new lenses fitted, you will discover that this approach to value creation contains a number of fallacies.

What is value?

The most important fallacy is that only what is recorded in gross domestic product constitutes ‘value’. This is the same as saying that value is created only by paid work, and that is clearly not the case. Every day, a great many people (mainly women) perform unpaid care tasks that are of ‘inestimable’ value. Incidentally, that inestimable claim is not correct, because there are indeed estimates of the value of unpaid care work and these amount to as much as 215 billion euros, or a quarter of GDP.

The value of unpaid care work is estimated at as much as 215 billion.

Because of this fallacy, it may seem entirely logical in all cases to want to get a single mother on benefits or an informal carer receiving benefits into (paid) work. But that is only logical if the paid work genuinely represents greater value than the unpaid work they were already doing (but can no longer do because they are now in paid work).

Is this woman doing paid work, or cleaning her own home?

Externalities

A second fallacy is made by failing to take account of what economists call ‘externalities’, or external effects. In that case, the value (price) of an hour of work at, for example, Tata Steel is very likely an overestimate of its actual value. After all, this does not take into account the damage to health caused in the IJmond region, nor the damage inflicted on the climate.

For a great deal of work, it is not easy to determine what its value is.

Related to this, a third fallacy can also be identified. For a great deal of paid work in a modern economy, it is not easy to determine what its value is, because no price is paid for the products and services produced by that work. Take the work of a policy civil servant, for example. I was one myself for a while, so I am not cynical enough to think that work is ‘worthless’.

Danger: quantifying quality

But it is very complicated to express the added value of that work in monetary terms. For convenience, economists therefore usually assume that you measure the added value of a civil servant by the salary they earn. But that is circular reasoning, which wrongly assumes that a ministry pays someone only as much salary as the value they add.

Is the government really more productive if a civil servant produces more policy papers?

For civil servants and also for healthcare workers, there is often an alternative calculation method for (labour productivity and) added value, based on ‘performance’. For civil servants, this may involve numbers of policy papers, answers to parliamentary questions and more ‘products’ of that kind.

For healthcare workers, it concerns the ‘treatment’ of patients. In both cases, there is a major problem with the ‘quantification of quality’. After all, the qualitative added value to public health is not directly related to the number of knee operations or MRI scans. Indeed, there are many indications that some treatments do not even contribute to better health for an individual patient.

Be aware of the fallacies

All in all, it is a major policy risk to proclaim that ‘labour productivity must increase’ and then announce generic measures to achieve this. Especially if you are not aware of these fallacies. To prevent this, you need to consider once again what the purpose of different economic activities was (both paid and unpaid), and what their ‘real’ added value is.

About the author

Ronald Dekker is an independent labour economist at RoDeO Labour market intelligence.

Read also

Related posts

All articles
How does political preference influence your selection? More than you might think…

Sustainability goes on your CV after Biden's victory, then comes off again after Trump's. American workers are adjusting their profiles in droves to match the political climate. And employers are rewarding that, even at the expense of quality. What does research say about political preference in recruitment?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
How the practical training room is increasingly becoming the answer to staff shortages

Yesterday, another large practical training workshop opened in Tilburg, where the installers of tomorrow are being trained. Organisations are increasingly turning to their own practical training schools. Will they succeed in addressing the shortages?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
Arjan Elbers on Monkey Rock: ‘Talent must always come first, the rest can wait’

What makes recruitment truly valuable? For Arjan Elbers, the answer always starts with people, he says on the Monkey Rock podcast. 'Talent is never an afterthought, but always the starting point.'

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.