All articles

News

How does political preference influence your selection? More than you might think…

Sustainability goes on your CV after Biden's victory, then comes off again after Trump's. American workers are adjusting their profiles in droves to match the political climate. And employers are rewarding that, even at the expense of quality. What does research say about political preference in recruitment?

How does political preference influence your selection? More than you might think…

Candidates rarely talk about politics in a job interview. On their CVs, they do, but much more subtly. A single line in an old job description, such as ‘enthusiastic about sustainability‘, can speak volumes. And workers realise this. Research by Harvard Business School professor Joseph Pacelli shows, for example, that American jobseekers add and remove such lines in droves whenever political power changes hands.

Candidates rarely talk about politics in a job interview. On their CVs, it happens more often.

Using data from Revelio Labs, the researchers (Pacelli, Janet Gao and Jun Oh) tracked 2.9 million American workers at publicly listed companies. Between 2018 and 2025, they had all amended at least one previous job description. The researchers linked this to voter data to determine the workers’ political preferences. They also used Refinitiv Eikon to examine when companies spoke about ESG (environmental, social and governance) and DEI (diversity, equity and inclusion) during their quarterly calls.

Sustainability in, sustainability out

Their working paper ‘Partisan Resumes: ESG Signaling Over the Political Cycle‘, recently discussed in Harvard Business Review, shows that employers who are sensitive to such signals sometimes choose the candidate with the right words rather than the one with the best qualifications for the role.

And the numbers are substantial. In the month Joe Biden won the 2020 election, around 35,000 workers added ESG or DEI language to previous job descriptions on their CVs. After Donald Trump’s victory in 2024, around 12,000 workers removed such passages.

When Joe Biden won the election, around 35,000 people added ESG or DEI language to their CVs.

Workers with Democratic leanings added this kind of language more often than Republicans. Under Biden, the difference was around four times as large as during Trump’s first term. Many people who had added the terms under Biden removed them again during Trump’s second term, the research shows.

Republicans remain vaguer

Companies were just as involved. The number of companies committing to sustainable ESG goals for the first time on a quarterly call peaked at around 230 in the third quarter of 2020, just before Biden’s election victory. It then gradually fell to a handful by the end of 2024. Workers from both parties added ESG language as soon as prospective employers began committing to it publicly more often. There was a difference, however: Democratic-leaning workers chose specific wording, whereas Republican-leaning workers mainly chose vague and symbolic expressions.

The strategy also appears to work. Those who added ESG language were 2.6 percentage points more likely to change employers in the following year than colleagues who amended other parts of their CVs. They were also slightly more likely to receive an internal promotion. At the same time, those who switched jobs after adding ESG language scored 2 to 3% lower on predicted job fit, for example because they had fewer years of experience. In a separate analysis, each person hired was compared with five similar jobseekers. It found that fit carried around 10% less weight in determining who got the job when candidates had added ESG language, particularly during the Biden years.

‘Companies sacrifice quality for that political alignment.’

‘Companies are clearly willing to hire someone who is a poorer fit because they have added ESG language,’ Pacelli concludes. ‘It also shows that workers are aware of companies’ political preferences and respond strategically to them.’ According to him, this is ‘further evidence that politics is seeping into the business world’.

Earlier research pointed in the same direction

The fact that political preference plays a part in recruitment is not entirely new. In 2012, for example, American political scientists Karen and Thomas Gift sent 1,200 CVs in response to 400 vacancies. The CVs contained a Republican signal, a Democratic signal or no signal, such as work experience on the McCain or Obama campaigns of the time.

Those in the minority, however, were penalised.

In conservative Collin County, Texas, Republicans were more likely to receive a response; in progressive Alameda County, California, Democrats were. Strikingly, belonging to the local political majority offered no advantage compared with a neutral CV. Those in the minority, however, were penalised. The study was published in the journal Political Behavior.

A stronger preference than for shared origins

A larger-scale study is ‘Politics at Work‘ by Emanuele Colonnelli (Chicago Booth), Valdemar Pinho Neto and Edoardo Teso. They analysed the entire formal labour market in Brazil between 2002 and 2019, including the party preferences of millions of business owners and workers.

Their conclusion: business owners are more likely to hire people from their own party, and that effect is stronger than for shared gender or origins. An experiment with fictitious CVs also revealed a direct preference for fellow party members. Those party members earned more and were promoted faster, even though they were less qualified. Companies where this was particularly prevalent grew less rapidly than comparable companies, however.

It happens in Belgium too

Closer to home, Eline Moens (pictured below), Dyllis De Pessemier and Stijn Baert of Ghent University investigated in 2024 how recruiters respond to political involvement on a CV. They presented fictitious candidates to 250 recruiters in Flanders. Candidates who mentioned involvement with a political party were seen as less creative, open and empathetic, but more assertive.

Involvement with the Greens was associated with a greater chance of being hired.

Candidates associated with the radical-right Vlaams Belang faced the clearest penalty: they were hired less often, although they were no less likely to be offered an interview. Involvement with the Greens, by contrast, was associated with a greater chance of being hired. The negative effect was greater for vacancies requiring a higher level of education. There is a caveat, however: many of the results for individual parties did not hold up well after a statistical correction.

The Ghent researchers also show how little rigorous research has been done on the subject so far. Of all the field experiments on discrimination in recruitment between 2005 and 2020 in the Web of Science database, for example, only one concerned political preference (the Gift and Gift study). There were 143 on origins, 72 on gender and 21 on religion. Discrimination on the basis of political belief is prohibited in the EU; in the Netherlands, it is prohibited under the General Equal Treatment Act.

What can you do with this?

What is new about the work of Pacelli and his colleagues is that it shows that workers themselves actively respond to political developments by strategically adjusting their CVs to the prevailing political climate. He offers employers three pieces of advice. The first is not to rely too heavily on algorithms that screen CVs. ‘Be careful. It is easy to polish up your CV with buzzwords to get through the initial screening.’

‘There will always be political fluctuations. But what matters today may be gone tomorrow.’

The second is to keep skills and experience at the centre, because ‘those are the core competencies someone needs to do the job’. The third is to think very critically about how much weight to give political preference. ‘There will always be political fluctuations. What matters today may be completely gone tomorrow. It is important to hire someone for the long term.’

Read also

Related posts

All articles
How the practical training room is increasingly becoming the answer to staff shortages

Yesterday, another large practical training workshop opened in Tilburg, where the installers of tomorrow are being trained. Organisations are increasingly turning to their own practical training schools. Will they succeed in addressing the shortages?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
Arjan Elbers on Monkey Rock: ‘Talent must always come first, the rest can wait’

What makes recruitment truly valuable? For Arjan Elbers, the answer always starts with people, he says on the Monkey Rock podcast. 'Talent is never an afterthought, but always the starting point.'

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
Councils know they need to work together. Why does concrete action so often fail to follow?

Municipalities already often collaborate on recruitment, for example through joint traineeships or mobility centres. So why not share candidates too? A new initiative aims to put that idea into practice.

Redactie Redactie Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.