All articles

Praktijk

Why the hiring manager is the biggest saboteur (but not the biggest problem)

The hiring manager is generally seen as the biggest obstacle in the recruitment process. But the real problem turns out to be the feud between recruiters and HR, says Wim van den Nobelen. 'The solution does not start with pointing fingers, but with looking in the mirror.'

Why the hiring manager is the biggest saboteur (but not the biggest problem)

Last week, I reported on a survey into who is seen as the biggest saboteur in the recruitment process. Of the more than 200 votes, a majority of people (52%) believe that the hiring manager is the biggest saboteur. In terms of sabotage, recruiters themselves (23%) and HR (17%) are then reasonably close together. Very few people blame the candidate for recruitment processes often not going as you would like them to (8%).

This is not an opinion. This is a cry for help.

More than half therefore point to the hiring manager first and foremost. That is not an opinion. That is a cry for help. But there is something else striking in these figures: recruiters point to HR. And HR, in turn, points to recruiters. They are sabotaging each other, whilst both also point to the hiring manager.

Why do hiring managers score so highly?

  • No time, but plenty of demands. ‘We are looking for the best candidate!’ But for a briefing? No time. For feedback? No time. For interviews? Perhaps in three weeks. Meanwhile, the vacancy remains open, the team is overstretched, and the recruiter is judged on speed.
  • The growing wish list. Week 1: ‘Someone with technical skills.’ Week 4: ‘Oh, and people management, that is also very important.’ Week 8: ‘A.I. knowledge would also be very useful.’ The goalposts have shifted. 12 candidates have dropped out. Complete frustration.
  • Radio silence on feedback. CVs left sitting there. The recruiter sends WhatsApp messages, calls, emails. After two weeks: ‘Oh sorry, I was busy. This one is no good.’ Without explanation. Without direction. Time to call them off.
  • Urgency without availability. ‘We really are in a hurry!’ But the first interview is scheduled for three weeks’ time. The second round another two weeks later. The best candidate? They have long since started somewhere else.

Read this article in full

Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.

Sign up now

No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment

Related posts

All articles
Alexander Duijmelinck on rejecting candidates better: ‘Really, 80% of recruiters should experience being dismissed at least once…’

Recently, he spent some time 'on the other side of the table' himself. There, Alexander Duijmelinck was reminded how impersonal recruitment processes often still are for candidates in practice. In particular, the way they are rejected. Surely we can do better?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
The next step for AI in staffing (and why your own database is crucial)

All recruitment agencies have invested heavily in AI in recent years. But the tools you have are also available to your competitors, as became clear yesterday at the first so-called CTO Lab. So where will tomorrow's competitive advantage come from?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
Despite AI concerns, demand for developers is on the rise again

Despite concerns that AI would take over most coding work, the number of developer vacancies is on the rise again. AI is having a major impact in another way, however: developer vacancies now call for knowledge of it.

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.