It may seem like a great catch when a true superstar in their field presents themselves as one of your candidates. Even when actively sourcing, you would naturally prefer to look for the real high-flyers, the people with the best reputation, who are widely recognised as top performers. Because, honestly, who would not want to add a Messi or Ronaldo to their squad? That may indeed be attractive in football, but it is different in the day-to-day reality of recruitment. Not only does such a superstar often prove disappointing afterwards, hiring someone like that can actually be counterproductive.
Poaching the best people from competitors can reduce your own performance by 10%.
Earlier research, for example, had already shown that a ‘superstar’ employee can hinder innovation or reduce the performance of current employees. More recently, several new studies have been added, which more or less reinforce the same conclusions. And this month, Harvard Business Review published a study by the universities of York and Paris, showing that a department that poaches the best staff from a competitor performs 10% less (!) a year later than a department that does not.
Read this article in full
Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.
No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment