All articles

Selectie & assessment

Why gut instinct almost always leads us astray in the job interview

The job interview has something in common with the CV: often criticised on all sorts of points and ultimately difficult to defend, yet still stubbornly part of almost every procedure. Is there actually an alternative conceivable?

Why gut instinct almost always leads us astray in the job interview

We had suspected it for some time. But large-scale new meta-research confirms it once again: the job interview is of little use. Whether they are conducted in a structured or unstructured way, such interviews can explain only 9% of the variation in employee performance, meaning no less than 91% is not taken into account. Interviewers usually think they can assess certain skills in their candidates very well, but in practice very little of this proves to be true, according to the researchers, who assessed a sample of more than 30,000 people.

‘Job interviews are often cooking competitions in which you are not allowed to taste the dishes.’

In fact, the outcome of many job interviews is determined precisely by an interviewer’s gut feeling about a candidate, in other words unconscious bias. It is often as if an experienced chef has to judge a cooking competition but, instead of tasting the dishes, is only allowed to interview the participants about their recipes, according to Eindhoven University of Technology-affiliated organisational consultant Llewellyn E. van Zyl. ‘Sounds absurd, doesn’t it? Yet this recruitment process is exactly how we have handled the lion’s share of hiring over the past 200 years.’

Read this article in full

Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.

Sign up now

No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment

Related posts

All articles
How does political preference influence your selection? More than you might think…

Sustainability goes on your CV after Biden's victory, then comes off again after Trump's. American workers are adjusting their profiles in droves to match the political climate. And employers are rewarding that, even at the expense of quality. What does research say about political preference in recruitment?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
How spy glasses can infiltrate your recruitment processes too

There is a great deal of debate worldwide about 'smart camera glasses'. This is also, or rather increasingly, true in recruitment. After all, who is really answering your questions? And what can you do about it?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
‘Rising unemployment among migrants raises questions about discrimination’

Unemployment among people with a migrant background is rising faster than among other Dutch people. And yes, labour market discrimination is one explanation, says Hanneke Felten (Movisie). But the good news is that something can be done about it...

Werf& gastredacteur Werf& gastredacteur Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.