All articles

Koen's Map

Koen’s card (25): What if you actually gave a reason for a rejection?

'You're not a good fit.' Why not? 'We can't tell you that.' Candidates are often left with vague rejections like these. But find a clearer reason, and your entire recruitment process can improve, says Koen Roozen.

Koen’s card (25): What if you actually gave a reason for a rejection?

Ouch… A candidate calls you after being rejected. ‘Why was I rejected? I’d like to learn from it.’ You hesitate over your answer. In truth, you have no clear reason, just a vague feeling. You say: ‘We chose someone with more experience.’ But this candidate actually had more experience. The real reason? The manager thought he was ‘not energetic enough’. But you can’t say that.

The real reason? Well, you can’t really say that…

The candidate on the other end of the phone can tell you’re avoiding the question. He thanks you politely and hangs up. Later, you see a post appear on his LinkedIn: ‘Took a day off to apply for a job. Then X rejected me without a good reason.’

Why do we keep doing this? Because we’re afraid of conflict or legal problems. ‘What if the candidate argues?’ So we reach for vague but safe excuses: ‘someone else had more experience’, ‘a better match’, ‘not a good fit for the team’. But vagueness helps no one. The candidate learns nothing. And you don’t discuss the rejection internally either, because if you can’t say it out loud to the candidate, you can’t explain it clearly to your colleagues. Because no one raises the issue, you keep making the same mistake.

This week’s card

This week’s card puts its finger on exactly this kind of avoidance. ‘Rejected candidates don’t know why we said no, and we don’t discuss it internally either. What are we missing as a result?’ The question for reflection is challenging: ‘What if we added one sentence to every rejection: “This was the reason”? What conversations would that prompt – internally and externally?’

If you can’t clearly explain a reason for rejection, you can’t justify it either.

Why this question works. This question forces you to move from glossing over things to being clear. By asking ‘what conversations would it prompt?’, the focus shifts to exploring, providing evidence and learning from one another. Together, you discover that if you can’t clearly explain a reason for rejection, you can’t justify it. That realisation is painful but crucial.

Discuss this with your team for 10 minutes. Look at the last 5 rejections and write down: exactly why was this candidate rejected? Compare your notes and feedback. Is the reason specific or vague? Choose 1 concrete action: identify a reason we don’t dare or aren’t able to say out loud, and stop using it. This is the first step towards fairer selection and a better candidate experience.

The secret of the trade

A rejection without an honest reason is a missed opportunity in 2 ways. The candidate doesn’t learn what he needs to improve. Perhaps he lacks 1 specific skill that he could easily develop, or didn’t express himself well. But because you give reasons outside the candidate’s control, to be on the safe side, he doesn’t discover where he could improve. Meanwhile, you learn nothing either. If you never discuss reasons for rejection with colleagues, you’ll never spot patterns. Perhaps the organisation systematically rejects candidates over 45 for vague reasons.

What you can do tomorrow? Tomorrow morning, you can review your last 10 rejections and ask yourself whether you could say the reason to each candidate. If so, do it. If not, why not?

Responding to resistance:

  • Team member: ‘What if candidates get angry or start arguing?’
  • You: ‘If we don’t dare tell them the real reason, perhaps it isn’t good enough to base a decision on.’

What will probably happen? The first time you give specific feedback can be daunting. But candidates usually respond with understanding and say: ‘It’s disappointing to be rejected, but now I know what I need to work on.’ Some ask for tips. And perhaps the candidate will apply again a year later, this time with that skill.

If you do this consistently, you’ll notice that honest feedback also makes internal discussions more focused.

If you do this consistently and discuss it with managers, you’ll notice that honest feedback also makes internal discussions more focused. If you have to explain why someone isn’t a good fit, you first need to be clear about it yourself. After a few months, you’ll see that rejections become clearer. That’s when you know: this works.

About the author

Koen Roozen trains and advises organisations on strategic recruitment and coaches managers. His work is based on analysis, clear models, direction and professional expertise. He developed the Recruitment management model. With his recruitment strategy cards, he helps recruitment teams strengthen their ability to attract candidates step by step. Koen Roozen teaches recruitment strategy at the Academy for labour market communication and writes about recruitment every Tuesday in his newsletter Recruitment with a kick.

Don’t want to wait for the next question? Order your own recruitment strategy card deck. You don’t need any preparation or an external facilitator. Simply draw one card each week, discuss it with your team for 10 minutes and choose 1 concrete action. This way, you build a recruitment department that really makes a difference, step by step.

Read more

Related posts

All articles
Koen’s maps (24): Why do we keep thinking that a good conversation is enough?

In recruitment vertrouwen we nog te veel op 'het goede gesprek', ziet Koen Roozen. Maar zolang we niet gestructureerd interviewen blijven we volgens hem appels met peren vergelijken. Met alle gevolgen van dien.  

Koen Roozen Koen Roozen Read article
Koen’s cards (23): ‘What happens when recruitment hears too late what is needed?’

Als recruiter word je vaak pas gevraagd in actie te komen als het MT een besluit al genomen heeft. Dat is te laat, zegt Koen Roozen. Maar hoe kom je dan eerder aan tafel?  

Koen Roozen Koen Roozen Read article
Koen’s cards (22): Why do candidates feel like a number?

Kandidaten onthouden niet dát ze zijn afgewezen, maar hóé ze dat zijn, weet Koen Roozen. Waarom zou je daar dan als recruiter niet een beetje meer tijd voor vrijmaken?

Koen Roozen Koen Roozen Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.