It has been known for much longer that an average job interview is a very poor predictor of success. According to international recruitment guru Dr John Sullivan, a key reason is that the topics that really matter are not always discussed. And that, in turn, is due to a lack of structure, he says. ‘Research clearly shows that the accuracy of an average job interview improves significantly when you switch from unstructured to structured interviews.’ And how does he believe you can best do that according to him? With a simple scorecard…
‘By assessing all candidates against the same yardstick, you increase the reliability of your selection process…’
‘Use a scorecard as a structured assessment list on which interviewers score pre-defined, role-specific criteria’, says Sullivan, who believes this can deliver as much as 40% better results. ‘Think of skills, experience or behaviour. All, of course, aligned with what is genuinely needed to succeed in the role. By assessing all candidates against exactly the same yardstick, you increase the reliability of your selection process and limit the influence of bias, assumptions or noise.’ Yes, hiring managers are not always keen on it, he knows that too. But according to him, there are certainly arguments that should convince them as well.
Read this article in full
Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.
No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment