All articles

Praktijk

From gut feeling to objectivity: 7 insights to improve selection

The CV and the 'click' with the candidate often still determine the choice in a selection process. But they say little about future success. How can it be improved? A new white paper, based on scientific research, offers 7 insights. What are they?

From gut feeling to objectivity: 7 insights to improve selection

More than 90% of HR professionals cite objectivity as a priority in selection. Yet 94% of Dutch organisations still use the CV as their primary selection tool – even though there is no scientific evidence whatsoever that it predicts future job performance. That is the core of the paradox described by Rikkert Walbeek, CCO and co-founder of the TA Audit Institute, in a new white paper on fair selection, which combines research based on 1,500 mystery applications at 245 larger Dutch organisations with a major study by Tilburg University among more than 600 HR professionals.

Almost all employers still rely – wrongly – on a CV.

In everyday practice, bias still plays a very major role in selection decisions for vacancies – in all sorts of ways – as both studies show. But the big question, of course, is: how can it be improved? These are the 7 most important insights Walbeek shares:

#1. The CV predicts…? Absolutely nothing

The CV is by far the most widely used selection tool in the Netherlands, but scientifically it is also the least reliable. There is not even a single study showing a significant correlation between CV content and actual job performance, Walbeek points out. Yet almost every selection procedure begins with it. The researcher describes the CV as ‘a collection of proxies‘: indirect signals that we unconsciously interpret as evidence of quality. A well-known employer or a particular university city, for example, says more about someone’s socio-economic background than about how they will perform in the role.

Read this article in full

Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.

Sign up now

No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment

Related posts

All articles
Alexander Duijmelinck on rejecting candidates better: ‘Really, 80% of recruiters should experience being dismissed at least once…’

Recently, he spent some time 'on the other side of the table' himself. There, Alexander Duijmelinck was reminded how impersonal recruitment processes often still are for candidates in practice. In particular, the way they are rejected. Surely we can do better?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
The next step for AI in staffing (and why your own database is crucial)

All recruitment agencies have invested heavily in AI in recent years. But the tools you have are also available to your competitors, as became clear yesterday at the first so-called CTO Lab. So where will tomorrow's competitive advantage come from?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
Despite AI concerns, demand for developers is on the rise again

Despite concerns that AI would take over most coding work, the number of developer vacancies is on the rise again. AI is having a major impact in another way, however: developer vacancies now call for knowledge of it.

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.