Like the invention of fire. Ask Google CEO Sundar Pichai how he sees the development of A.I. and he makes this comparison. That is how great he believes its impact will be. But in this new reality, what will happen to recruitment? And, importantly, what will happen to recruiters? ‘A.I. changes everything,’ says Kevin Wheeler. ‘Computers will soon speak at a level where people can no longer tell whether they are talking to a machine or a human being. Although human judgement will still be needed, the traditional tasks of many professions, such as recruiters, are likely to be replaced by automated tools.’
[private limit=”” roles=”werf_subscriber_unpaid”]
Such tools will have ‘an enormously expanded knowledge of human social behaviour after analysing social media and online interaction. With a complete memory, vast amounts of information and the ability to integrate and combine data sources, the power of A.I. is almost limitless,’ says the recruitment guru.
Four scenarios
The Future of Talent Institute-founder recently set out 4 scenarios for the year 2028. A worthwhile exercise, he says. ‘By thinking about a number of wild possibilities, we can see what might happen and what we would do if it did. The real value of scenarios is that they help us make contingency plans and psychologically help us get a grip on the future.’
Scenario 1: No more recruiters
The first scenario Wheeler outlines is one in which computers, artificial intelligence, machine learning and blockchain automate the recruitment process almost entirely. ‘Hiring managers will no longer need recruiters because they will have access to powerful apps that will do everything. From creating job requirements to sourcing, screening, assessing and recommending an appropriate salary.’
‘Hiring managers will no longer need recruiters because they will have access to powerful apps that will do everything.’
‘They will also communicate with candidates and, using personality screening, engage them in ways that will keep them interested. With access to company data, strategic plans and other business information, these automated systems can help decide which roles should be permanent, contract or part-time. Candidates will also be able to take automated tests to demonstrate their skill level.’
Scenario 2: Automated, with a human touch
Scenario 2 is quite similar to scenario 1, but with a more human touch. ‘A.I., machine learning and blockchain will enhance recruitment in this scenario. Hiring managers will be central to the process and will first use apps to find candidates and speak to them. Recruiters will be available to provide advice and guide the manager.’
‘Recruiters will play a more important advisory role at a later stage.’
‘In this scenario, recruiters will play a more important role at a later stage, applying the human touch in the final contact and negotiations. Although A.I. will help establish job requirements, screen candidates and advise on selection, the recruiter and the hiring managers will still make the final decisions. A.I. will be an adviser and perhaps even a coach for hiring managers, recruiters and candidates.’
In this scenario, he also envisages a major role for A.I. in supporting candidates. ‘Candidates will use apps to access more in-depth information about the company, its strategic and financial goals, and possible career opportunities. Tools such as Glassdoor have evolved to predict whether a candidate would be happy in that organisation based on their personality and knowledge of the company.’
Scenario 3: Recruiters as advisers
In scenario 3, the recruiter’s role shrinks somewhat further. ‘Hiring managers, for example, can use an app to help them draw up job requirements and advise them on where to advertise the vacancy. Another app can assess and rank candidates. Other applications can make an offer to the candidate. But whichever apps they choose, they will still need a recruiter for advice and to do certain things, such as interviewing and closing candidates,’ says Wheeler.
‘Whichever apps they choose, hiring managers will still need a recruiter for advice and to do certain things.’
According to him, recruiters are needed in this scenario ‘to provide advice, coach hiring managers and guide the process. They can also use apps to gather information, chat with a candidate or assess their skills. Meanwhile, candidates will look to see whether they can find roles that match their skills, personality and values.’
Scenario 4: No recruiters, but talent concierges
In scenario 4, traditional recruiters no longer exist; instead, we only speak of “talent concierges”. ‘In this scenario, much work has been automated and the need for employees has fallen drastically. Most companies have only a handful of employees who use a network of consultants, contractors and other non-permanent staff. Offices and physical workplaces are rare and exist only to make products, provide healthcare or serve the public, such as restaurants and hotels.’
‘Most people work remotely and occasionally meet with colleagues to exchange ideas and work on projects. Hiring production or service staff is automated. Because volumes are small and the required skills are varied, most professional needs are met through personal referrals, networks or, in rare cases, using A.I. tools or a talent concierge.’
‘Talent concierges are very similar to the older profession of headhunter or RPO, but with a twist.’
‘Talent concierges are external professionals engaged on a case-by-case basis to fulfil specific needs with the right person. This is very similar to the older profession of headhunter or RPO, but with a twist,’ states Wheeler. ‘The talent concierge has the technical skills to carry out quality checks and resolve issues with automated systems, ensure algorithms are ethical and prevent fraud. Concierges are usually senior recruiters who have developed technical and coaching skills and have extensive business knowledge.’
‘No one can predict the future’
Wheeler is known for his thought-provoking predictions for the recruitment profession, but he too is only too aware of the danger of predictions. ‘None of us can predict the future,’ he stresses firmly. ‘The future will unfold in ways we cannot foresee. The scenarios I propose are probably inaccurate, but they are an attempt to think logically about how things might evolve given A.I. and the changing demographics and work ecosystems we see emerging.’
This article previously appeared on Recruitment Valley.
[/private]
Want to know more?
On 9 November, the first annual conference ‘AI & Recruitment 2023‘ will take place. On this day, various leading speakers from the sector will discuss the impact of A.I. on recruitment, both corporate and agency-side. Technology providers with experience in this field will also speak, and various best practices will be presented.
Read also
Read this article in full
Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.
No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment


