I’m a fan of De Verraders. People trying to work each other out, seeing clues everywhere and sometimes becoming so convinced by their own reasoning that nobody can persuade them otherwise. As a headhunter, I find it fascinating to watch. Especially at the round table, when suspicions turn into accusations and everyone tries to convince the others that they are right.
Apparently, how someone makes their point can carry more weight than the point itself.
What strikes me every time is that, as a viewer, I know who the traitors are. So I also know when someone is absolutely right in their accusations. And yet I catch myself thinking: do you have to speak to someone like that? I agree with that person, but they irritate me at the same time. Apparently, the way someone makes their point can carry more weight than the fact that they are right.
A label and a judgement
The same thing happens in job interviews. The difference is that afterwards we write an assessment of the other person. And then ‘I didn’t find it an enjoyable conversation’ can all too easily become ‘the candidate responds defensively to challenging questions’. Take someone who has changed employer 3 times in 4 years. As a recruiter, you want to know more about that. But if you start with ‘You do seem to be a job-hopper’, you are essentially asking someone to refute your judgement.
If you start with ‘You do seem to be a job-hopper’, you are not asking an open question.
You haven’t yet heard why they left, but you have already given it a name. And made a judgement. The candidate then explains at length why it wasn’t their fault. They choose their words carefully, try to correct your assumptions and may come across as a little tense. What do you write down then? That they take little responsibility? That they struggle with feedback? Or also that you labelled them first?
A question with a tone
In our profession, we talk a lot about assessing people objectively. We work with scorecards, competencies and set questions. But a question on paper has no tone. The recruiter asking it does. ‘Why did you leave that job?’ can express interest, but also disbelief. Especially if the recruiter adds ‘so soon’, sighs or raises an eyebrow.
We like to think that an interview reveals what someone is like. But does it?
We like to think that an interview reveals what someone is like. Sometimes, what we mainly see is how someone responds to us. That distinction matters when we recommend whether or not to hire someone based on that conversation. It happens the other way round too. ‘Why should I choose this company?’ is a fair question. Especially if someone is happy where they are and I am the one who approached them. They can rightly expect me to explain why this move might be worth considering.
Go on, convince me
Sometimes, though, what I hear in a question like that is mainly: go on, convince me. As if I first have to prove that the company is worth their attention. Then I stop thinking about what this move could offer them and start thinking about how they will conduct themselves when they meet my client. The question is fair, but the tone gives me doubts I didn’t have before.
Even with a fair question, the tone can give me doubts I didn’t have before.
That is information too. Especially when someone will be expected to lead a team or have difficult conversations with clients. But before I label that ‘arrogant’, I want to know whether I see the same behaviour elsewhere. And whether I simply find it difficult when a candidate asks me some challenging questions.

Not accepting easy answers
We can usually justify our own directness. We want to ask follow-up questions, refuse to be fobbed off and dare to raise difficult subjects. Yet when a candidate shows that same directness, we are quicker to call it difficult. As a result, the person who gives us the most pleasant conversation may also get the most credit.
Questioning a candidate rigorously is not an achievement in itself.
That seems to me a more relevant problem for recruiters than whether we dare to be critical enough. Questioning a candidate rigorously is not an achievement in itself. You also need to learn something from it. If someone is mainly occupied with defending themselves against your assumptions, after an hour you may be thoroughly convinced of your judgement, but you still won’t know why those 3 jobs were so short-lived.
In De Verraders, that is part of the game. But a job interview is not a game. I don’t need to expose anyone. I want to know whether someone is suitable for a role. So before I write ‘Responds defensively’ in my report, I prefer to take another look at my own question and the tone in which I asked it. Otherwise, that assessment may say more about how I conducted the conversation than about the candidate.
About the author
Isabel Verhelst is a results-driven, no-nonsense coach with a passion for connecting people. She is the owner and founder of Talent to Match, a boutique agency focused on top C-level talent that is a perfect fit for an organisation’s DNA. Her belief: the people you bring in determine where your company will be in 3 years’ time. She writes a blog on this site every other Tuesday.
Read also
- ‘Employer branding is too often an excuse not to be visible’
- Do you dare to challenge the brief?
- ‘Competency matrices…? The best reveal themselves in just 5 minutes’
- Isabel’s choice: Why explosive dinners sometimes teach me more than interviews
- Why we reject brilliant leaders – sometimes before they have said a single word
- All Isabel’s choices
