All articles

Candidate experience

Ronald Dekker: ‘Can the labour market’s information problem really be solved?’

The labour market is a complex system, like an ant colony, Ronald Dekker observes. According to him, the information problem is therefore persistent. But will we ever be able to solve it?

Ronald Dekker: ‘Can the labour market’s information problem really be solved?’

The labour market is a complex system, just like an ant colony. Everything and everyone swarms around each other, and it is extraordinarily unpredictable what will emerge from the system. Even when you know how those ants behave on average, you cannot explain, let alone predict, what the outcomes will be. It is no easy task to search in such a system for ants that must make a useful contribution to your own sub-colony or organisation. Even when you know what work the ants need to be able to do and will be doing.

The labour market is a complex system, just like an ant colony.

Recruitment and selection are therefore difficult professions. After all, you cannot tell from someone’s nose whether they are suitable for the work you need done. Economists call this an ‘information problem’. And as applies to all problems in economics: you can make money from them. The labour market’s information problem is enormous, which means a great deal of money is made from it. A great deal of money. Recruitment and HR companies around the world will generate €632 billion in revenue in 2025 alone. And that does not even include recruitment activities within companies and employment services provided by the government.

Money well spent

And now we can only hope that all of this is indeed ‘money well spent’. And that, through all these efforts, more people end up in a place in the labour market that suits them. So that companies suffer less from labour shortages, workers can express themselves better in their work and are therefore both more productive and happier. I do not want to give anyone in the world of recruitment and selection a complex, but there still seems to be much to gain in this respect. Because after years of recruitment technology and promises of matching through AI algorithms, the Babylonian confusion of tongues (‘the information problem’) in the labour market seems greater than ever.

We simply keep failing to agree on an Esperanto-like skills standard.

Everyone is therefore waiting for one another, or reinventing the wheel themselves, for example with a self-invented skills language. We simply do not seem able to agree on an Esperanto-like standard. In the Netherlands, we are making reasonable progress with CompetentNL (an open, flexible standard that can ‘talk’ to other existing and new skills languages), but it is painfully slow.

Babylonian confusion of tongues

And that is not necessarily due to incompetence on the part of the government or the other parties involved (at least: not solely). Commercial parties in particular believe they have an interest in maintaining the permanent Babylonian confusion of tongues at macro level. Because this enables them to create and sell attractive recruitment solutions at micro level, for individual companies and sectors. When the problem is solved at macro level, the foundation disappears from their business model. So it is not in their interest to cooperate with it.

Information is and remains the problem in the labour market.

Long story short: Basket! Or no, actually: information is and remains the problem in the labour market. And anyone who promises to solve it completely should be treated with suspicion.

About the author

Ronald Dekker is an independent labour market expert at RoDeO Labour market intelligence.

Read more

Related posts

All articles
Koen’s cards (22): Why do candidates feel like a number?

Kandidaten onthouden niet dát ze zijn afgewezen, maar hóé ze dat zijn, weet Koen Roozen. Waarom zou je daar dan als recruiter niet een beetje meer tijd voor vrijmaken?

Koen Roozen Koen Roozen Read article
LinkedIn loses ground among jobseekers (but no real alternative has emerged yet)

LinkedIn is increasingly losing ground among jobseekers, according to new research by Intelligence Group. But is there already a fully fledged alternative available?

Geert-Jan Waasdorp Geert-Jan Waasdorp Read article
Make preboarding not only welcoming, but measurable too: 3 role questions before day one

Preboarding often involves nothing more than a great deal of information transfer. But it is also a good time to discuss behaviour and clarify expectations, says Buket Çiçek (QuizFlight). What does she envisage?

Werf& gastredacteur Werf& gastredacteur Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.