A no-poach agreement in which you agree not to recruit each other’s staff? The European Court of Justice recently showed it a clear red card. The ruling, which arose from a Portuguese football case, has implications far beyond sport. Recruiters and HR professionals in other fields who make informal agreements with one another not to approach each other’s employees are now also on thin ice, it appears. So what exactly does the ruling mean? An explanation, in two halves, plus injury time…
Kick-off: what happened?
In April 2020, almost all Portuguese clubs from the first and second divisions came together. The competition had been suspended due to coronavirus, contracts were expiring and the fear was real: wealthy clubs could sign players from competitors before the season resumed, thereby influencing the outcome. The clubs agreed not to poach each other’s players – only for the duration of that extended season, only for players whose contracts had been terminated because of coronavirus and only within Portugal. The Portuguese competition authority nevertheless considered this to be an infringement and imposed fines. The clubs challenged this, and ultimately the Portuguese court asked the European Court of Justice for clarification.
Read this article in full
Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.
No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment