All articles

Praktijk

Isabel’s choice: ‘The leader who worked yesterday can sink you tomorrow’

Many organisations look for someone with a proven track record when filling a vacancy. But the past is rarely a good predictor of the future, Isabel Verhelst observes. It can even stand in the way of renewal, she makes clear.

placeholder Isabel’s choice: ‘The leader who worked yesterday can sink you tomorrow’

I hear it all the time. ‘We are looking for someone who has done this before.’ A board of directors or CEO looking to recruit the next leader opts for the comfort zone of experience. Same role, same challenges, preferably in the same sector, ideally with impressive results too. On paper, that sounds logical. Proven success feels like the safest choice. But here is the uncomfortable truth: what worked yesterday can become your greatest risk tomorrow.

The experience trap

Management author Adam Grant calls it thinking again: daring to question your assumptions. And one of the most persistent assumptions in executive hiring is that past success guarantees future results. It does not. The context changes faster than your candidate’s CV.

The context changes faster than your candidate’s CV.

I have seen leaders who looked like the perfect match on paper, with a flawless track record and glowing references, yet within a few months they became a brake on growth. Why? Because they kept reverting to the same playbook. Copy-paste from the past. Yesterday’s solutions applied to today’s challenges.

Read this article in full

Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.

Sign up now

No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment

Related posts

All articles
placeholder Koen’s cards (26): how do you ensure consistency across the entire organisation?

Hiring managers often feel that their department is so unique that a standard process simply won't work. But 'inconsistency undermines everything', says Koen Roozen. How, in his view, can you enforce the same process across the organisation, whilst leaving room for tailoring?

Koen Roozen Koen Roozen Read article
placeholder Alexander Duijmelinck on rejecting candidates better: ‘Really, 80% of recruiters should experience being dismissed at least once…’

Recently, he spent some time 'on the other side of the table' himself. There, Alexander Duijmelinck was reminded how impersonal recruitment processes often still are for candidates in practice. In particular, the way they are rejected. Surely we can do better?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
placeholder The next step for AI in staffing (and why your own database is crucial)

All recruitment agencies have invested heavily in AI in recent years. But the tools you have are also available to your competitors, as became clear yesterday at the first so-called CTO Lab. So where will tomorrow's competitive advantage come from?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.