All articles

Wim on Wednesday

Wim on Wednesday: Why your gut has no opinion

The Gut Excuse, that is what Wim van den Nobelen calls the vague opinion without arguments that is not uncommon in recruitment. 'If your gut feeling disappears as soon as someone asks 'why do you think that?', then it was not intuition, but prejudice.'

Wim on Wednesday: Why your gut has no opinion

There is a term that has been getting on my nerves for a very long time. A term that crops up in meeting rooms, by the coffee machine, and especially in job interviews. A term that sounds as though you possess wisdom, when in fact you simply have no idea what to say. ‘My gut feeling says…’ What do we actually mean when we talk about our ‘gut feeling’? Let us be honest: it is an elegant way of saying: ‘I have an opinion but no arguments.’ It is the adult version of ‘because’ in answer to the question: ‘why?’

Your gut feels hunger. Your gut feels pain after a poorly chosen shawarma at 3 o’clock in the morning. But your gut has no vision for the marketing budget, no thoughts on recruitment, and certainly no wisdom on complex social issues.

The democracy of laziness

The problem with ‘gut feelings’ is that they put everyone on the same level. The surgeon with 20 years of experience? Gut feeling. The conspiracy theorist who gets their information from Facebook? Also gut feeling. Both equally valid, because who are you to question someone’s gut? This is intellectual laziness in designer packaging. When did we stop thinking and start feeling? When did it become uncomfortable to say: ‘You know what, I do not know enough about this’, or: ‘Let me think about that’?

Read this article in full

Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.

Sign up now

No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment

Related posts

All articles
Wim on Wednesday: why everyone must keep developing (except HR…)

As recruiters, we know that experience matters. But are we willing to put our own experience to the test, asks Wim van den Nobelen. 'Your gut instinct could do with a performance review too.'

Wim Van den Nobelen Wim Van den Nobelen Read article
Wim on Wednesday: how much of recruitment still relies on people?

Recruitment is a people business, Wim van den Nobelen often hears. But, he asks, why is your next competitor looking only for candidates and not for staff?

Wim Van den Nobelen Wim Van den Nobelen Read article
Wim on Wednesday: ‘We’re still alive. But stay indoors, just to be safe…’

It seems that we are finding it increasingly difficult to deal with risks, observes Wim van den Nobelen. The same applies to recruitment. With all the consequences that entails. 'Being thorough helps. But at some point, you have to dare to choose.'

Wim Van den Nobelen Wim Van den Nobelen Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.