This week, I am delving into a question that concerns every recruiter and hiring manager: how do I choose the right candidates? Or rather: what is the best way to select the right candidate? We have a whole arsenal of tools at our disposal. But which method really provides the best prediction of success in the role?
The recruiter’s toolbox
What exactly is in the recruiter’s toolbox?
- The CV – The classic. It provides a good overview of someone’s career, but does it tell the whole story? People are simply better at writing down their successes than their learning points.
- The covering letter – Increasingly less popular, but some organisations still swear by it. It provides insight into writing skills and motivation, but is it authentic or a well-coached story?
- Assessments and tests – From personality tests to cognitive abilities. Objective and measurable, but do they capture the whole picture?
- The job interview – The core of almost every procedure. Personal contact, feeling the chemistry, the opportunity to ask follow-up questions. But also: susceptible to bias and personal affinity that has nothing to do with the role.
- References – Insights from people who really know the candidate. Valuable, but do you get the honest story? And how representative is a reference chosen by the candidate themselves?
- Role plays – Let candidates act out a situation they may encounter in the role. Realistic and practical, but also artificial and potentially stressful.
- The job shadowing day – The ultimate reality check. Candidate and team get a taste of reality. Time-consuming, but perhaps the most honest method?
- Or perhaps another method?
Read this article in full
Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.
No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment