A confidentiality clause in a settlement agreement often aims to protect both the employee’s privacy and the employer’s reputation. Nobody wants gossip about the reason for leaving or the amount of a severance payment. But what if such confidentiality is used to conceal poor performance? The intended protection can then become an obstacle. After all, during a reference check, a recruiter cannot possibly form an accurate picture of a candidate. The candidate will not mention it and the employer may not.
A minefield of interests
A confidentiality clause in a settlement agreement is usually a neutral arrangement, but it can create a minefield of conflicting interests. Looking at three parties, you have:
- The employee: Has the right to privacy protection, but what if poor performance was the reason for leaving? How fair is it then to keep this completely hidden from a potential next employer?
- The referee (former employer): Is caught in the middle. A reference must be honest, but confidentiality sometimes makes that impossible. What are you still allowed to say without breaching the agreement?
- The recruiter and new employer: Have the right to transparent information in order to make a sound decision. But what if that information is not available? Is that candidate immediately ruled out?
Read this article in full
Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.
No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment