All articles

Flex & staffing

Why skills-based recruitment is far from a miracle cure

Skills-based hiring is often hailed as a panacea for labour shortages and stalled recruitment processes. But anyone who wants to make a real success of it needs to learn a few lessons, says Dr John Sullivan. What are they, according to him?

Why skills-based recruitment is far from a miracle cure

From astrology to graphology and numerology; they are still used in selection methods around the world. Yes, in Japan, even a candidate’s blood type is still examined to determine their personality, a practice known as ketsueki-gata. None of these is a panacea, but rather ‘voodoo practices’ when it comes to selection, according to internationally renowned recruitment guru Dr John Sullivan. Yet it is according to him often the harsh reality that many organisations fall back on as soon as they drop a degree as a qualification requirement from a vacancy.

‘Widespread use does not yet prove that the skills-based hiring process is actually effective.’

The rise of skills-based hiring may sound appealing in theory, he says. But unfortunately, the reality is not yet quite so rosy. Last year, for example, it emerged that of every 100 vacancies that did not require a degree, only 3.5 were ultimately filled by someone without a relevant degree. Moreover, there is still little more than anecdotal evidence that such skills-based hiring actually results in better hiring decisions, according to Sullivan. ‘Widespread use does not yet prove that the skills-based hiring process is effective – even though 81% of employers now report that they use these more skills-focused methods.’

Read this article in full

Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.

Sign up now

No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment

Related posts

All articles
Agency work as a stepping stone? It turns out to be disappointing…

Back at work quickly, but at a price. Those who start working through a temporary employment agency after a bankruptcy still earn 20% less per hour 7 years later, Leiden research shows.

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
No vacancies at the moment? Now is the time to start recruiting!

The pressure on the labour market has eased, so the planned employer branding campaign can be put on ice. Right? This is an understandable reaction, but also somewhat short-sighted, says Jet Bouwman. 'It is precisely now that you lay the foundations for future success.'

Jet Bouwman Jet Bouwman Read article
Is LinkedIn really about to make its most important clients redundant?

LinkedIn is piloting a Full Service Hiring service, offering a combined human and A.I. workflow for finding, screening and presenting candidates to organisations. Is the company now also taking aim at recruiters themselves?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.