All articles

Wim on Wednesday

Why recruiters see candidates who are not there: rose-tinted glasses or a magnifying glass?

The halo and horn effects are well-known pitfalls for recruiters. They lead to rose-tinted glasses, or an unjustified magnifying glass on any mistakes, says Wim van den Nobelen. How can you avoid these pitfalls, according to him?

Why recruiters see candidates who are not there: rose-tinted glasses or a magnifying glass?

Recruiters have a special gift: they see potential. That is usually a good quality. Until it goes too far. Then the halo effect emerges. A candidate has a strong CV, comes across confidently, has worked for a well-known company or shares the same hobby as the hiring manager. Suddenly, all their other qualities are automatically seen in the same light. Leadership? It will probably be fine. Team fit? Undoubtedly excellent. Dealing with complex stakeholders? It will work out.

Recruiters have a special gift: they see potential. That is usually a good quality.

But there is also the opposite: the horn effect. One less strong quality and the candidate is immediately downgraded. A tiny gap in their CV. An average presentation. A spelling mistake. A less well-known employer. Suddenly, nothing seems good enough any more.

Recognising biases

Both thinking errors have the same consequence. We do not assess the candidate sitting in front of us. We assess the story we have made up ourselves. Perhaps that is one of the biggest challenges in recruitment. Not finding talent, but recognising our own biases. After all, a candidate is not better because we want to believe they are. Nor are they worse because we dislike one detail.

Read this article in full

Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.

Sign up now

No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment

Related posts

All articles
Wim on Wednesday: why everyone must keep developing (except HR…)

As recruiters, we know that experience matters. But are we willing to put our own experience to the test, asks Wim van den Nobelen. 'Your gut instinct could do with a performance review too.'

Wim Van den Nobelen Wim Van den Nobelen Read article
Wim on Wednesday: how much of recruitment still relies on people?

Recruitment is a people business, Wim van den Nobelen often hears. But, he asks, why is your next competitor looking only for candidates and not for staff?

Wim Van den Nobelen Wim Van den Nobelen Read article
Wim on Wednesday: ‘We’re still alive. But stay indoors, just to be safe…’

It seems that we are finding it increasingly difficult to deal with risks, observes Wim van den Nobelen. The same applies to recruitment. With all the consequences that entails. 'Being thorough helps. But at some point, you have to dare to choose.'

Wim Van den Nobelen Wim Van den Nobelen Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.