All articles

Visie

Why objective selection so often fails on motivation

Recruiters who work professionally naturally invest in structured interviews, says Wim Thielemans. Yet, according to him, many selection interviews founder on one surprising factor: motivation. So how can you approach that in a structured way?

Why objective selection so often fails on motivation

Recruiters who work professionally invest heavily in structured interviews. Yet many objective selection interviews founder on one surprising factor: motivation – precisely the part where STAR(R) and skills-based hiring let you down. Because how do you see through socially desirable answers here? Hardly anyone has ever learnt how to assess motivation objectively, and that is exactly where most of the noise arises in selection interviews.

Hardly anyone has ever learnt how to assess motivation objectively.

A good interview produces a clear signal: useful information about who someone is and how they work. But as soon as you assess one element on gut feeling, you mix noise into that signal. The signal itself does not change – the candidate remains who they are. You simply can no longer distinguish what is genuinely information from what is your interpretation.

Persistent myth

More and more organisations now work with structured interviews and skills-based selection. A positive development – in a previous article, I described why that structure lies primarily in the thinking before the interview: first the role, then the criteria, then the questions, then the scorecard. But precisely when motivation and attitude come up, the structure often disappears again.

Read this article in full

Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.

Sign up now

No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment

Related posts

All articles
Permanent jobs are already becoming less permanent: numbers are rising, but average tenure is falling

In the debate about labour market flexibility, the mantra that permanent jobs should be less permanent is often heard. Recent figures show that this is already happening.

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
Word of the week: Central Casting. What on earth does that mean?

Some people look as though they have been sent by a casting agency. What exactly does Central Casting mean, where does the expression come from, and why do Dutch recruiters still fall for it every day?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
Wendy’s world: ‘Who actually decided this had to become a vacancy?’

When someone leaves, we recruiters often rush straight to filling the vacancy. But according to Wendy Goudzwaard, that means skipping an important step: what work actually needs to be done?

Wendy Goudzwaard Wendy Goudzwaard Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.