‘Good energy’. A ‘friendly demeanour’. Or simply: a ‘nice person’. They may seem like harmless compliments, but they can play an unduly large role in the selection process. According to new research by Textio, which analysed more than 11,000 interview assessments from the past three years, these descriptions appear to be more decisive in hiring than many employers might like. Those who are considered nice ultimately stand a much better chance of getting the job.
Candidates who ultimately received an offer were no fewer than 12 times more likely to have been described as someone with a ‘great personality’. Terms such as ‘nice’ (6x more often), ‘friendly’ (5x) and ‘energetic’ (4x) also appeared strikingly often for successful applicants.
‘Nice is not a competency’
In other words: managers prefer people they like. That is not, in itself, a shocking observation. But the fact that such subjective terms find their way into formal interview reports is nevertheless ‘concerning’, according to Textio co-founder and CEO Kieran Snyder. ‘If you hire people based on personality rather than skills or learning ability, you undermine your organisation’s future performance,’ she says. It turns selection into a kind of popularity contest. One that is not equally fair to everyone.
Read this article in full
Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.
No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment
