The labour market is tight, but the main problem is that there is a shortage of ‘good jobs’. Both the renowned Turkish-American economist Dani Rodrik and Utrecht professor Sonja Bekker say much the same thing, about the United States and the Netherlands respectively. And both are quite precise about what constitutes a good job.
‘A good job gives you four things: income, stability, professional expertise and autonomy.’
In the propositions accompanying my doctoral thesis, I once argued that it was not for me, as a researcher, to determine what is a good or bad job. But Rodrik and Bekker rightly point out that a great deal of research has been done into what working people themselves consider to be a good job. They are not thinking solely of employment conditions such as a good salary, but also of a certain degree of influence over and autonomy in their work. In addition, many working people value a certain degree of security and predictability, as well as the opportunity to improve at their work.
Learning from manufacturing
Traditionally, we regard old-fashioned ‘jobs for life’ in manufacturing as good jobs. But according to Rodrik, this causes us to focus too much on employment in manufacturing for the wrong reason. All over the world, not only in the US but also in China, industrial employment is declining rapidly. Globally, we have become so good and efficient at making things that we need ever fewer people to do it.
‘Globally, we have become so good and efficient at making things that we need ever fewer people to do it.’
So when it comes to good jobs, we can no longer rely on manufacturing, but rather on service sectors such as healthcare, which Rodrik identifies as the undisputed biggest driver of employment growth. Manufacturing can, however, serve as an example of how technological innovation and automation can create good jobs. In manufacturing, smart automation means retaining sufficient autonomy and development opportunities in the work.
In many Western countries, this has largely been secured by trade unions. The Japanese Lean philosophy also places limits on automation, because it recognises that ‘people’ cannot be entirely replaced in production processes. Productivity gains and better jobs go hand in hand. And that does not mean automation automatically leads to better jobs. It may also be that striving for – or securing – better jobs leads to more successful automation. Either way, automation without attention to the quality of work has less beneficial effects than automation with it.
Buurtzorg as a blueprint
The question now is whether that beneficial combination can also be achieved in service sectors such as healthcare. In the podcast, Rodrik refers to the Dutch organisation Buurtzorg (‘Boertsorgh’), where self-managing teams have led to efficiency and cost benefits whilst the quality of work has been maintained. This can be seen, among other things, in lower staff turnover. High turnover is both a huge cost to the organisation and a major red flag for problems with the quality of work.
‘Employees who experience a better quality of work generally provide better services.’
In Dutch healthcare, it has long been known that the shortage is not necessarily a recruitment problem, but rather a turnover problem that cannot be solved through recruitment alone. An approach to labour market shortages in healthcare therefore cannot do without attention to the quality of work. It is also known that the quality of care – as experienced by patients – correlates strongly with the quality of work in healthcare – as experienced by healthcare staff. Broadly speaking, the same applies to education and other service sectors: employees who experience a better quality of work provide better services.
Start with the people already working there
Employers in service sectors, particularly healthcare, would therefore do well to focus on smart automation. In other words: doing more with fewer people. This also means involving all the smart people already in their employment in thinking about that automation. It makes their work more interesting and gives them a greater sense of autonomy and development. This increases both productivity and the quality of work. Create good jobs in healthcare. That is the only way to deliver good care sustainably. As long as jobs are not good enough, more campaigns will not solve the shortage.
About the author

Want to know more?
View the full programme for the Recruitment & Healthcare conference in Utrecht on 21 May.
Recruitment & HealthcareRead also
- Ronald Dekker: ‘Can the labour market information problem actually be solved?’
- ‘Job losses for young people due to AI? There is no reason to panic yet’
- This was the month in recruitment: 7 things that caught our attention in December 2025 (with podcast!)
- Why we are heading for ‘Jobs Chaos’ in 2026 (and no, it is not an apocalypse)
- AI and the automation of work in the Netherlands: an evidence-based analysis


