All articles

Flex & staffing

Is Thomas Piketty the new John Maynard Keynes (and will we soon be working much less)?

Just as John Maynard Keynes predicted 100 years ago, star economist Thomas Piketty also believes that by the year 2100 we will all have much shorter working weeks. Ronald Dekker doubts this, as work is increasingly becoming a leisure activity too.

Is Thomas Piketty the new John Maynard Keynes (and will we soon be working much less)?

The now world-famous French economist Thomas Piketty argues (here, for example) that, in order to keep the economic system operating within planetary boundaries, we need to work much less. The equally famous British economist John Maynard Keynes predicted something similar around 100 years ago: that, thanks to technological development and the resulting higher labour productivity, we would only need to work 15 hours a week in the future.

Even in the ‘Netherlands, part-time country’, more people are working now than ever before, and on average considerably more than 15 hours a week.

In the end, Keynes’s prediction came to nothing. Even in the ‘Netherlands, part-time country’, more people are working than ever before, and on average considerably more than 15 hours a week. People apparently have infinite creativity when it comes to devising ‘things to do’ for payment. This is primarily evident in the growth of paid jobs in activities that previously took place ‘for free’ within households. Grocery and meal delivery, childcare, cleaning services, washing and ironing are all activities that – far more than 50 years ago – are outsourced to paid workers.

Progress?

This has mainly meant that far more women than before have paid work. And it is therefore also responsible for part of the economic growth during that period. After all, we do not measure unpaid work in households in Gross Domestic Product, whereas paid work ‘in the market’ is measured. Whether you consider this progress or not depends somewhat on your political position.

Back to Piketty. In the Global Justice Report by his World Inequality Lab in Paris, he writes about the ‘economy of enough’ (‘sufficiency’) and argues that in 2100, just over 70 years from now, people worldwide will work far fewer hours on average: 1,000 a year (roughly 20 hours a week), rather than 2,100 hours (around 40 hours a week now). As Keynes once did, he argues that productivity growth will make this possible without sacrificing prosperity. Furthermore, according to Piketty and his colleagues, the distribution of paid work between men and women will be virtually equal by 2100.

Enjoyment

According to Piketty, the reduction in weekly working hours has two important causes: first, countries have historically used their productivity gains to enjoy more free time. Second, keeping the planet liveable will become an important reason to produce less, in material terms, and therefore less work will be needed. The question now is: is Piketty a better forecaster than Keynes was? We all know: ‘Forecasting is difficult, especially when it concerns the future’ (according to Niels Bohr, Danish physicist and winner of the 1922 Nobel Prize).

And it is to be expected that Piketty, too, is making a prediction here that will not come true. As stated earlier: people are infinitely creative in inventing new paid work, despite their preference for more free time. And it is likely that, since Keynes, paid work has also become a ‘consumer good’ for many people, meaning that they no longer regard ‘an extra hour of paid work’ as something for which they give up an hour of free time, but as something that provides them with ‘utility’ and improves their lives.

Climate boundaries

And it is entirely possible that all this new work will fit comfortably within the planet’s climate boundaries. After all, we are still shifting towards a service economy, which usually requires fewer physical resources than an economy focused on making ‘things’. In short, Piketty’s aim of a much shorter working week on average will founder on our infinite creativity in devising paid work and our need to want to take part in that paid work. Let us hope that we retain enough time for the highly necessary unpaid work, which will still exist in 2100.

About the author

Ronald Dekker is an independent labour market expert and ‘practical thinker’ at RoDeO Labour market intelligence.

Also read

Related posts

All articles
Agency work as a stepping stone? It turns out to be disappointing…

Back at work quickly, but at a price. Those who start working through a temporary employment agency after a bankruptcy still earn 20% less per hour 7 years later, Leiden research shows.

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
No vacancies at the moment? Now is the time to start recruiting!

The pressure on the labour market has eased, so the planned employer branding campaign can be put on ice. Right? This is an understandable reaction, but also somewhat short-sighted, says Jet Bouwman. 'It is precisely now that you lay the foundations for future success.'

Jet Bouwman Jet Bouwman Read article
Is LinkedIn really about to make its most important clients redundant?

LinkedIn is piloting a Full Service Hiring service, offering a combined human and A.I. workflow for finding, screening and presenting candidates to organisations. Is the company now also taking aim at recruiters themselves?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.