What lies behind the remarkable yet determined crusade by the EEOC against the relatively small Meathead Movers? Why must this California-based moving company, founded in 1997, suddenly pay a fine of $15 million for alleged age discrimination, jeopardising its survival? It is the central question that the Goldwater Institute, a conservative think tank from Arizona, wants answered in a lawsuit it recently brought against the federal US anti-discrimination body, officially called the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
The case is indeed unusual in many respects. For instance, it is almost unheard of for the EEOC to bring a lawsuit against a company without an individual claimant having sought damages. The EEOC’s approach is also remarkably persistent: it has been investigating the company since 2015 and has never agreed to settlement proposals involving non-financial requirements, such as changing the training and revising the wording of the company’s slogan. And this at a time under Trump, when the independent agency already has a difficult time. So why be so persistent here?
Athletic movers
The case centres on Meathead Movers, a family business that presents itself as a company offering ‘athletic movers’ who are ‘polite, strong and professionally trained’. With that slogan, it has grown into California’s largest independent moving company, now with seven branches. Although most people working there are indeed young, and often still students, people of other ages work there too. Nevertheless, the EEOC claims that Meathead ‘engages in a pattern or practice of recruiting and hiring young students, deliberately excluding older workers regardless of their individual abilities.’
‘When employees start looking for a job after graduating, Aaron proactively calls recruiters to recommend them.’
A 2017 profile in Inc. magazine does seem to give the EEOC some support on this point. Brothers Aaron and Evan Steed speak at length about their vision and the foundation of their business: ‘energetic athletes who deliver a unique customer service experience’, which can also be ‘a springboard for their careers’. ‘When employees start looking for a job after graduating, Aaron proactively calls recruiters to recommend them.’ To that end, the article states, ‘the company recruits its more than 350 movers – mainly wrestlers, but also American football and baseball players – from universities across California.’
Looking for rejected applicants over 40
When these employees are not moving furniture, they jog to and from the lorry. A business model that may look athletic, but which the EEOC considers discriminatory, particularly on the grounds of age. The anti-discrimination watchdog is therefore still actively looking for ‘individuals aged 40 and over who applied to Meathead and believe they were not hired because of their age’. But this has so far produced no complaints. So the EEOC brought a case itself. Something that had occurred only eight times before in the past 10 years, as Dylan Foreman of local NBC station KSBY noted in March this year.
When employees are not moving furniture, they jog to and from the lorry.
It is therefore hardly surprising that CEO Aaron Steed now openly wonders why he is the one being targeted, and has already had to spend $1.5 million on legal costs, without there being any other injured parties besides themselves. Nor is it surprising that the Goldwater Institute is happy to support him, demanding in a lawsuit ‘all documents relating to the total number of complaints against Meathead Movers and publicly available information about the EEOC’s investigation into Meathead Movers’. After all, this gives them a useful opportunity to draw attention to their conservative agenda.
‘Please apply!’
Meanwhile, Aaron Steed is still unaware of having done anything wrong. ‘It has always been like this with us: can you do the job or not?’, he says. ‘We do not care what you look like or how old you are. It is about whether you can meet Meathead’s requirements. In fact, if someone over 40 can work to the Meathead Movers standard and accepts the same pay as ours, then please apply. Please apply. As if running a small business in California was not difficult enough, we are being sued for a crime we did not commit. But this company is worth fighting for.’
”We do not care what you look like or how old you are. It is about whether you can meet our requirements.’
The EEOC itself said it could not comment on ongoing litigation, but it previously explained in a civil complaint that since 2017, Meathead Movers has ‘depicted exclusively young people in Meathead Movers’ online marketing, recruitment and training materials, including on its website, social media, physical merchandise and posters in Meathead Movers’ physical workplaces.’ And that this therefore amounts to implicit age discrimination. Even though the EEOC itself acknowledges that some degree of physical capability is, of course, quite a logical job requirement for a moving company. To be continued, undoubtedly. Literally.
Read also
Photo credit: Meathead Movers
Read this article in full
Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.
No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment


