In the first half of 2022, demand for recruiters peaked at a level never seen before. A collapse followed in the final quarter of 2023, but demand recovered in the first quarter of 2024 to just below the level of the same period in 2023 (index=88). This puts the current level at roughly that of mid-2021, when there was also explosive demand for recruiters. A major difference from that period, however, is that more recruiters are now available, meaning supply – both permanent and flexible – is higher.
Demand for recruiters is roughly at the level of mid-2021, when there was also explosive demand.
The huge shortage of recruiters experienced at the time is therefore considerably smaller today, as shown by the Compagnon HR and Recruitment Report 2024. A recruiter actively looking for work can still choose from 3 vacancies. The figures differ for assignments (self-employed professionals), but the interplay of supply and demand is not comparable to the labour market for ‘permanent jobs’ either.
Source: Jobfeed.nl[/caption]
Agencies are hiring recruiters again
It appears to be agencies that are hiring more recruiters than direct employers (corporates). This is partly because they experience greater recruiter turnover, as they have traditionally focused more on junior professionals, and partly because, with 20,000 agencies, they are increasingly orchestrating how the labour market works. And that naturally requires manpower.
20,000 agencies are increasingly orchestrating the labour market.
The greatest demand is particularly among agencies active in secondment, self-employed intermediary services, brokers and international recruitment, rather than recruitment and selection or temporary employment agencies. The latter group is more likely to be quietly restructuring, as the temporary employment sector has not been performing well for a long time and changing legislation and an increase in the minimum wage will not improve this in the short term (table 17).
Source: Jobfeed.nl[/caption]
Notably, rising demand for recruiters appears to be moving slightly faster among direct employers than among agencies. This is partly because, in the final months of 2023, self-employed professionals wanted to return to employment (less demand), and a larger share of the budget is being spent on tooling. At the same time, there is a growing call, particularly in healthcare, education and government, to be less dependent on agencies. So far, this has mainly translated into lip service and policy documents rather than the development of in-house professional recruitment departments (whether or not with the help of RPO providers). The latter is necessary, however, given the continued scarcity in the labour market.
Demand will increase further
Whilst many agencies are understandably concerned about the expiry of the enforcement moratorium on false self-employment (which may of course still be extended), I nevertheless foresee greater demand for recruiters. If the moratorium ends, the shortage will not disappear. Direct employers will therefore have to recruit more themselves (demand for recruiters), whilst agencies will not simply let their good, trained recruiters walk out the door. Such a change also always creates a great deal of additional work and questions that require extra capacity. Including to document and administer matters even more thoroughly.
Recruiters therefore have a good year ahead of them, regardless of the improving economy.
AI will not have solved this by 2025 either. In fact, in the short term AI will create more work for recruiters, because increasingly ‘good’ applicants will make it through preselection. Now that candidates are embracing AI en masse, this creates much more work for recruiters because they still have to follow the recruitment process ‘traditionally’. Fortunately, providers such as RecruitAgent.ai and Scotty offer solutions for this. But as with so many technological developments, costs come before benefits. Recruiters therefore have a good year ahead of them on this International Recruiter Day, regardless of the improving economy.
Read also
Read this article in full
Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.
No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment
Source: