All articles

Events

5x Monique Kremer on migration: ‘Businesses must take responsibility’

The debate around migration has hardened considerably. But we cannot do entirely without labour migration either. Therefore: 5 ideas from Advisory Council on Migration chair Monique Kremer on how we can work towards solutions.

5x Monique Kremer on migration: ‘Businesses must take responsibility’

Few issues are as charged these days as migration. Anyone looking for nuance in the debate can turn to the Advisory Council on Migration, an independent advisory body established by law that advises ‘politicians’ in the broadest sense on migration. Its chair is Monique Kremer, who will also deliver the opening keynote on 14 February at the very first Congress on the Internationalisation of the Labour Market ever held in the Netherlands. What 5 ideas can we expect to be discussed there, among others?

#1. Broad prosperity

Labour migration is not simply good, nor simply bad, according to the Advisory Council on Migration in the report Realism around targets, published late last year. Kremer had long advocated using ‘broad prosperity’ as the starting point for policy. In other words: is it only about meeting employers’ need for workers? Is it about a well-functioning labour market? Or is it about the quality of life in the Netherlands in general?

At present, we often only talk about labour migration when shortages arise in the labour market. But why should we not try to pursue proactive policy that carefully considers which forms of labour migration are desirable? The December report also cites the so-called ‘Canadian model‘ in this regard. ‘How Canada sets and uses targets can offer inspiration for the Netherlands.’ Targets can help guide migration in the right direction. However, the report also warns: ‘Do not use indicative figures as an end in themselves, but make them part of a broad vision of migration.’

#2. Citizens’ assemblies

An interesting argument in the report concerns the citizens’ assembly. This instrument is already being used in many municipalities in the Netherlands to involve citizens in thinking about, for example, the energy transition. But why not use it for migration too? In Canada, citizens are asked through surveys how many migrants are welcome. In the Netherlands, this could very well be done through a citizens’ assembly, according to Kremer, who is also Professor of Active Citizenship.

‘Everyone can see that there are staff shortages.’

She is not afraid that one person will say inflow should be reduced to 0, whilst another wants to welcome everyone. ‘Then you underestimate society’, she told Het Parool only last month. ‘People think more nuancedly than you think. Almost nobody says “just shut the door completely”, and almost nobody says “just open the door completely”. Everyone can see that there are staff shortages.’

#3. Partnerships

A shortage of staff on the one hand, and a lack of housing and public support among large sections of the population on the other. It is not easy to navigate between them. But why should we not try to make concrete agreements with some countries about the conditions under which migrants come to the Netherlands? According to the Advisory Council on Migration, this could create a win-win situation for both countries. Indonesia and Tunisia could be suitable countries for such a partnership, Kremer told NOS last year.

‘When you look at the shortages, it is very unwise to bury your head in the sand.’

This concerned in particular long-term care, where ‘distressing situations’ are already arising because staff shortages mean that ‘necessary, appropriate care’ is unavailable to an increasing number of people. Targeted migration, particularly from outside the European Union, could largely alleviate that problem, according to Kremer. ‘Labour migration from outside Europe is still something of a taboo. That is unwise. When you look at the shortages, it is very unwise to bury your head in the sand.’

#4. An integration fund

However, Kremer also sees that the conditions in which migrants live must be in order. ‘Labour migration policy also means that, as a government, you do a great deal on housing and integration and thereby ensure there is public support’, she says. In that context, she recently argued in the FD that businesses should take more responsibility too. ‘Migrant workers who stay must be enabled to learn the language and develop themselves so that they can move into other work. Employers should therefore contribute to a fund for civic integration and integration.’

‘If employers only want migrants to circumvent the system, that is detrimental to everyone.’

You must also help people develop, she believes. ‘Nobody grows old in logistics.’ And at the very least ensure strict compliance with the rules. ‘The labour inspectorate and other inspectorates that must oversee these rules are effectively our new customs posts’, she told de Volkskrant in 2015. ‘You should not cut back on that. If we ensure that nobody in the Netherlands is paid less than the minimum wage, fewer migrants will come too. Why do employers want to employ them? If it is only to circumvent the system, that is detrimental to everyone and we must keep those migrants out.’

The debate around migration has hardened considerably. But we cannot do entirely without labour migration either. Therefore: 5 ideas from Advisory Council on Migration chair Monique Kremer on how we can work towards solutions.

#5. The German approach

Opponents of migration often refer to the ‘Danish model’. Kremer prefers to look at the German approach, where according to her the government does virtually ‘everything’ differently and better than in the Netherlands. ‘The government says: we need to take control. There, migration is an integral part of labour market policy’, she recently said in Het Parool. But in the Netherlands, she says, far too little thought is given to this. ‘The government has done nothing for too long. Yes, then migration happens to you. But the Cabinet can pull far more strings and take much more initiative.’

‘More is possible than you think, and more than is happening now.’

EU rules mean that labour migrants from other Member States cannot be excluded, but the Cabinet can intervene by forcing companies to pay higher wages, offer permanent contracts and improve working conditions. This will naturally make it less attractive to hire cheap workers from abroad. Kremer (who is also a member of the advisory board of UWV Werkbedrijf) also advocates more direction over which companies come here. ‘More is possible than you think, and more than is happening now.’

More about Monique Kremer?

Listen to what Monique Kremer said at BNR last year about recruiting and selecting migrants:

More about global recruitment?

On 14 February 2023, Werf&, together with Intelligence Group and Decisio, is organising the very first Congress on the Internationalisation of the Labour Market ever held in the Netherlands. It will cover, among other things, the most popular professions for knowledge workers and just how attractive the Netherlands is to jobseekers from abroad. Monique Kremer will deliver the opening keynote. Want to know more? Look here.

Congress internationalisation

labour migration congress

Read this article in full

Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.

Sign up now

No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment

Related posts

All articles
TikTok and Instagram are no longer just for younger jobseekers

Those looking to reach more senior jobseekers may not immediately think of social media such as Instagram and TikTok. Wrongly so, as new figures show.

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
Is hiring an AI agent now also a job for the recruiter?

HR must no longer concern itself solely with human employees, but increasingly with digital ones too, Josh Bersin noted during UNLEASH in Paris. But what does that mean for recruiters?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
10 lessons we learnt at Digitaal Werven 2026

Digitaal-Werven experienced its 20th edition yesterday, under the motto Welcome to the Future. A.I. was once again virtually everywhere, but the best stories were at least as often about real people, clear choices and honest figures.

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.