All articles

Visie

Wendy’s world: ‘Who actually decided this had to become a vacancy?’

When someone leaves, we recruiters often rush straight to filling the vacancy. But according to Wendy Goudzwaard, that means skipping an important step: what work actually needs to be done?

Wendy’s world: ‘Who actually decided this had to become a vacancy?’

An employee leaves. The role becomes vacant. The old job advert is brought out, a few lines are amended and recruitment is asked to find a replacement. But for me, that immediately raises an interesting question. Who actually decided that exactly the same role is needed again?

Why is recruitment still so often simply asked to find a replacement?

Perhaps the work has changed by now. Perhaps certain tasks have become much more important than they were 3 years ago. Or perhaps someone in the current team could take on some of the work. Perhaps the problem the organisation now faces calls for very different talents from those the person who left originally brought. Yet the search often begins with a vacancy.

Matching outdated requirements

And as soon as that vacancy is defined, quite a lot has already been decided. Job title, qualifications, years of experience, competencies, hours and sometimes a whole list of desirable attributes. We then look for people who match them as closely as possible.

I would rather start much earlier, with the work that needs to be done.

I would rather start much earlier, with the work that needs to be done. What needs to be better here in a year’s time? What problem needs to be solved? What knowledge is currently missing from the team? What could someone contribute to help this team or organisation move forward? Only then does it become interesting to ask what kind of person would be a good fit and what the role should look like.

Additional experience and skills

I have spent many years working with professionals on the other side of the interview table, and I see how much talent is overlooked when a job profile becomes the main guide. People are ruled out because their job title is different. Someone may have spent years solving precisely the kinds of problems the organisation is now grappling with, but lacks 1 formal requirement. Another candidate may not match the profile exactly, but brings knowledge and skills gained from 30 years of experience that could benefit the whole team. That additional experience and expertise is not in the job advert, but comes as part of the package.

And then something sometimes happens that truly amazes me. There are 75 applicants. In the end, none of those 75 is considered good enough. A few weeks later, the same vacancy is advertised online again. Same job title. Same requirements. Often almost exactly the same wording. If you were 1 of those 75 people, what would you think? My main thought is: how likely is it that, among 75 people, there really was no one with knowledge, experience or talent that could benefit this organisation?

Back to the drawing board

For me, that is the moment when recruitment and the hiring manager need to go back to the drawing board. What were we actually looking for? Which requirements proved genuinely important? On what grounds did we reject candidates? Were we mainly looking for someone like the person who left? And did we pay enough attention to what people did bring? As far as I am concerned, that conversation is part of good recruitment.

A recruiter is more than someone who advertises a vacancy and puts candidates forward.

A recruiter is more than someone who advertises a vacancy and puts candidates forward. Recruitment knows the labour market, sees what is available and often quickly notices when a wish list bears little resemblance to the people actually out there. So use that expertise. Ask a hiring manager why a particular requirement is necessary. Ask what happens if someone can perform 80% of the role exceptionally well and also brings something the organisation had not thought of at all beforehand.

Not a copy

Explore whether the work can be distributed differently and whether the talented person sitting in front of you might be much better suited to another role. Then you suddenly start looking at things differently. Perhaps you are not looking for a new copy of the employee who left. Perhaps someone internally can progress and you need external expertise for another part of the work. Perhaps you meet someone with an unconventional CV who understands exactly which problem you want to solve.

A hiring manager cannot hand a vacancy to recruitment as though placing an order.

For me, that is where recruitment becomes interesting. You look at a person and ask: where can this talented person add the most value in our organisation? That question goes beyond filling a vacancy. And it also involves taking ownership. A hiring manager cannot simply hand a vacancy to recruitment as though placing an order. Nor can recruitment thoughtlessly publish a job profile. Together, you decide what you are asking the labour market for.

What is really needed?

If 75 people then apply and none meets the requirements, that also says something about what you are asking for. Perhaps we should therefore start less often with the vacancy and more often with what an organisation really needs. After all, the most interesting candidate does not always fit the profile written yesterday. Sometimes the talent is already in front of you, and you simply need to be perceptive enough to see where you can put it to use.

About the author

Wendy Goudzwaard is a careers and job application expert, strategic coach, LinkedIn trainer, keynote speaker and LinkedIn Top Voice. As the founder of Omgekeerd Solliciteren®, she has spent more than 17 years working on the other side of the interview table. Drawing on that experience, she takes a critical look at how recruitment and selection processes affect candidates and what is needed to achieve better matches.

Related posts

All articles
Permanent jobs are already becoming less permanent: numbers are rising, but average tenure is falling

In the debate about labour market flexibility, the mantra that permanent jobs should be less permanent is often heard. Recent figures show that this is already happening.

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
Word of the week: Central Casting. What on earth does that mean?

Some people look as though they have been sent by a casting agency. What exactly does Central Casting mean, where does the expression come from, and why do Dutch recruiters still fall for it every day?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
Cuts to the Dutch tax authority: who will still want to work there?

At the beginning of this year, the Dutch tax authority launched a fresh campaign to shed its dull image. In October, however, the government announced cuts of €438 million, whilst staff shortages may already be leaving billions uncollected. How can the two be reconciled?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.