All articles

Internationaal recruitment

Why a superstar is not always the ideal candidate

On this final day of the transfer window, many football clubs are still paying millions for a genuine superstar. But they are not always the best candidates for that position in that team. What lessons does this hold for recruiters?

Why a superstar is not always the ideal candidate

[private limit=”” roles=”werf_subscriber_paid”]

The final day of the transfer window, always exciting. Which football club will still bring in which superstar (in the making)? Who will manage to sign tomorrow’s Messis and Ronaldos, preferably at a reasonable price too, so that a sale once they attain genuine superstar status brings in the top price? It is undoubtedly fun for fans to follow. But as everyone knows: 11 Haalands do not make a winning team. With 11 Mbappés, it is also questionable what sort of teamwork will materialise on the pitch. And even a (former) superstar such as Henderson or Mario Götze always turns out to be human after all.

‘Hiring a superstar comes with hidden costs that may outweigh the potential benefits.’

The analogy with the world of recruitment is striking. Recruiters too often say they are looking for that one superstar, the best in their field, with a proven track record of experience and potential, a reputation for brilliance, willing to take the new team to new heights too. But success is not guaranteed here either. ‘The reality is that hiring a superstar comes with hidden costs – costs that may outweigh the potential benefits if they are not carefully managed’, according to Mark Murphy, CEO of consultancy firm Leadership IQ.

Read this article in full

Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.

Sign up now

No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment

Related posts

All articles
How spy glasses can infiltrate your recruitment processes too

There is a great deal of debate worldwide about 'smart camera glasses'. This is also, or rather increasingly, true in recruitment. After all, who is really answering your questions? And what can you do about it?

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
Location: the Moon. Anyone interested?
Feel Good Friday 8 min
14 nov 2026

Location: the Moon. Anyone interested?

There are plenty of candidates eager to become astronauts. But how do you select the best from the many applicants? A look behind the scenes at NASA, as a new recruitment round gets under way.

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article
How is AI really changing the world of work? (A closer look at 7 recent studies…)

Not a day goes by without new research into the relationship between work and AI. We round up 7 of the most recent studies and look for a common thread. Time and again, it turns out to be a desire for more training, more say and more policy.

Peter Boerman Peter Boerman Read article

Altijd op de hoogte van de ontwikkelingen op de arbeidsmarkt?

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest updates, news and invitations to our events.