Of all the studies conducted into the labour market and the way recruiters do their work, the annual survey by British ATS eploy is always one of the most interesting. For around 9 years now, together with HR Grapevine, they have asked 700 in-house recruiters how things are going (a little like our State of Recruitment), and this usually produces quite insightful results, which are also presented beautifully to readers. Here are 10 of this year’s most notable findings, which can probably also be translated quite well to the Dutch situation:
#1. Scarcity remains the biggest challenge
The scarcity of candidates remains the biggest challenge for recruiters. No fewer than 53% rank this issue number 1. However, this is much lower than in previous years: whilst it was still 61% last year, it was even 68% in 2023, a drop of 17 percentage points in 2 years. Other notable challenges include difficulty forecasting demand (30%), insufficient budget (23%) or insufficient capacity (22%), high turnover (20%) and even: too many candidates (18%).
#2. Candidate experience a priority (again)
Of course, challenges are also matched by priorities. As last year, the candidate experience appears to be at the top of the agenda – a subject that apparently proves a major task time and again. What stands out here is the low priority given to recruitment automation and AI (at 23%), whilst, for example, talent pooling (37%) and data & metrics (36%) score much higher.
#3. Referrals: high quality, usage could be better
Another recurring theme: according to respondents, referrals deliver the highest-quality candidates. But, as last year, they do not deliver the most candidates, and only 68% of respondents still say they ask their employees to put forward such word-of-mouth candidates. Recruiters in large organisations (>1,000 employees) even say that agencies are just as often responsible for bringing forward candidates as their own colleagues. And in most organisations, the hiring manager is also more responsible for putting forward candidates than employees themselves.
#4. Solutions sought internally
Notably, more than ever, organisations appear to be seeking the solution to their biggest challenge – the scarcity of candidates – internally. For example, 80% say they are looking at how they can upskill current employees for their hard-to-fill vacancies (up from 70%), whilst another 46% are focusing mainly on internal mobility (down from 52%). In the same category, 39% say they are investing in the talent of tomorrow, for example through training programmes for recent graduates. Collaboration is still ranked remarkably low here, as is recruiting and selecting people across borders.
#5. More candidates, more in-house recruitment
That in-house recruitment is on the rise is also evident from the question of what has changed most over the past 12 months. For example, 50% of respondents report that in-house recruitment has grown in their organisation, whilst only 19% deny this. At the same time, 60% have seen the number of applicants for their vacancies increase significantly, whilst only 17% saw a significant decrease. The number of recruiters who said they had filled more or fewer vacancies was more or less evenly balanced. Retaining talent, on the other hand, became slightly easier over the past year, according to most respondents.
#6. RMA: major opportunities remain
What other resources do organisations use to promote their vacancies, besides their own recruitment site? The study suggests there is still a world to gain here. For example, a majority do not use job alerts or email marketing, events or open days, and not even video (!). And among those that do, most use them only sporadically. The low use of video is particularly striking, whilst its impact is always significant.
#7. Measuring = knowing = performing
Cause and effect are somewhat unclear. But it is notable nonetheless: organisations that measure how effective the channels they use are perform better across the board than organisations that say they do not measure this. The leading organisations score higher in both candidate quantity and quality. With one exception: agencies. Organisations that also measure the work of their agencies actually receive fewer candidates in this way (although the quality of those candidates does increase slightly on average).
#8. Indeed dominates
Of all in-house recruiters, 61% say they work with job aggregators that collect vacancies from across the internet. Here, Indeed is the clear number 1 by a huge margin, followed at an appropriate distance by Google (for Jobs), Adzuna, Talent.com, Jooble and Jobrapido. Of the latter 4, 3 also saw a decline in use over the past year. Notably, 43% of recruiters say they sponsor free job listings (an increase from 40% last year), but a large majority therefore do not, sticking to free postings.
#9. Stating the salary is usually worthwhile
A current topic: is it wise to advertise with the salary from the outset, or is it better to keep that somewhat vague? This study shows that, in by far the most cases, it is worthwhile: it delivers not only more, but also better candidates. There are some exceptions, however: if you advertise vacancies with a salary through your own website, LinkedIn, programmatic advertising, specialised job boards, events or agencies, the number of applicants actually falls. Although, of course, you might assume that the number of disappointments later in the recruitment process will also decrease…
#10. Little besides vacancies on careers sites
The importance of the recruitment site can surely be assumed to be well known by now. Yet there is still a great deal to improve in this area. For example, 8% say they publish nothing other than vacancies on that careers site or the careers section of the general website. What else can be found there? Well, it is not much either. Around 80% do list company values, but everything else scores below two-thirds. Employee videos, for example? Found only among a minority. The same applies to explanations of the application process or FAQs. And only 6% have a chatbot to help the candidate.
The candidate appears barely interested in information about the leadership team.
Interestingly, the researchers also looked at the difference between well-performing sites, in terms of candidate quantity and quality, and less well-performing recruitment sites. The best-performing sites are 6 times more likely to include interview tips, 5 times more likely to have a chatbot, and 3 times more likely to have a section with information about diversity and FAQs. Information about the leadership team? It appears to make no difference whatsoever (in other words: candidates do not care). Including a piece of company history on your site even appears capable of costing you candidates: the best sites are, at least, less likely to include it than the less well-performing ones.
Want to know more?
Download the full report:
Read also
Read this article in full
Become a Werf& member for unlimited access to all articles, research and exclusive insights into the labour market.
No obligations Cancel anytime Secure payment